Based on 15 reviews.
City Paper Review
One day, years from now, when Amsterdam Falafelshops dot the landscape like the Middle Eastern answer to Five Guys, many of you will likely sit in the arty Adams Morgan original and bitch about how franchising has destroyed a once great fast-food restaurant. Actually, you might be able to start bitching sooner than that, if my recent checkup of the place is any indication of Amsterdam’s consistency. The fry basket is the operation’s stock-in-trade, but the cook must have been paying more attention to the overhead TV than to his station. My falafel balls were over-fried, tasting of oil and reeking of garlic, while the twice-fried fries were greasy and limp. And for reasons that probably don’t say good things about the American palate, the Dutch mayo tasted as if it were spiked with a sweetener, inching it closer to ketchup and away from the traditional tangy condiment. The really sweet thing, though, about Amsterdam Falafelshop continues to be its toppings bar—the self-serve spread offers almost everything, from spicy sauces to cool salads—which can cover up a multitude of sins, even chickpea balls fried to the consistency of hush puppies left overnight in a warming tray.
—Tim Carman,
June 22, 2007
Rater Comments
These comments express the opinions of individual Restaurant Raters, not those of Washington City Paper.
Review by greenzella on March 16, 2011
My husband and I visited DC. He was referred to this restaurant and ended up eating there twice in one day! He just wishes they had mail order!
Review by 20009 on September 1, 2010
We used to be huge fans of this place. But recently we visited with a friend and our two young children. The staff was literally abusive toward us and even yelled at our children. We used to love this place, but you won't be finding us there again.
Review by beginandjuice on January 25, 2010
Really fresh, love that there are tons of toppings to choose from and it's DIY. Well-priced, and the fries are incredible, especially with their mayonnaise.
Review by petrelupu on November 25, 2009
Definitely the best, fresh food available in town. The falafel is dead on authentic, fresh pita bread, their wonderful selection of made in house daily salads & toppings, and the fries, don't forget the fries (to die for).
Review by Good Eats on September 15, 2009
Not only is this the best place to get after-hours grub in the Adams Morgan area, it is the best falafel I've had in DC. The fries are also not your average fry--possibly double-fried if I were to guess. Basically, create your own falafel with the plethora of sauces and condiments they provide. AF is a must after a few cocktails in AM!
Review by jeanlucsgirl on April 22, 2009
One word---Mmmmmohmygodmmmmmmmm!
Why have I waited so long to come here?! Their falafel is delicious, and with the variety of differect toppings? Takes falafel to another level. I love the Garlic Cream sauce and the grilled eggplant. INCREDIBLE!!
Be warned: That Garlic Cream sauce lingers even after you brush your teeth, but it is SO worth it!!
Review by Melsner on April 22, 2009
I'm giving it 4 sporks because it's hard to find reasonably priced food in DC. Its cute, convenient, tasty, and cheap. That said, I was burping up that garlic sauce for a while.
Review by cicero on February 13, 2008
A friendly staff that is proud of its product, a hip-but-unpretentious vibe, and a decadent, do-it-yourself product makes Amsterdam one of the great treasures of the District. Sometimes I wish I knew what I was putting in my falafel, or that I had cash on hand (damn that $2.00 ATM fee!), but I suppose that's part of the charm. This is the only falafel shop I've found that measures up to L'As du Falafel on the Rue des Rosiers in Paris.
Review by m24679 on October 16, 2005
This is one of my favorite places in the city! It's inexpensive, quick and the falafel is really great. It's the best falafel I've ever had!
Review by deeps on August 2, 2005
Finally something different/cheap/delicious/quick in Adams Morgan! This place is going to take over soon, you just wait...
Review by n0r1 on January 24, 2005
Though the staff was a bit slow on dishing up the falafel, I was more than satisfied with the delicious and cheap dinner to be found here. The toppings bar is really the highlight -- not only your basic tahini (and -- vegans, rejoice! -- without yogurt in it!) and hummus, but chickpeas, nicely spicy cilantro and jalapeno, and much, much more. Now I know where to go for a quick 18th-Street dinner when nearby Julia's Empanadas is closed!
Review by GoodEatsPioneer on November 15, 2004
I'm a firm believer that there's a strong correlation between the number of things on a restaurant's menu and how good they are. Think Soup Nazi here folks. The Amsterdam Falafelshop only has two choices - Felafel and Fries. They do a pretty good job with both. The felafel are made fresh all day long, which is crucial, and there is a great variety of salads and sauces to add to your sandwich. The fries are double fried for crispiness, but there is nothing all that special about them- they're still just french fries no matter how many times you stick em in the fryolator guys.
Review by chadm on November 10, 2004
This place is a boon for neighborhood vegetarians and late-night revelers alike. The concept is simple leaving little room for error: Falafel and fries. The Falafel is some of the best I've had in the area, fries, on the other hand, are no better than average.
Review by hahn74 on October 25, 2004
This spartan take-out is open late enough to satisfy cravings at any hour. The line gets backed up but most times it's worth the wait. The falafels are crispy and are great canvases to create whatever art you want at their self-serve toppings bar.
Review by PaxRyan on October 12, 2004
Messy, messy, messy... but good (but, isn't this how all good things are??) I don't like that I have to make it myself, but the stuff is all so good that it comes out ok anyway:-)