columns: cheapseats
Show Comments Comments Print this article Print
Author: Dave McKenna
Author: McKenna
Issue: 2008/05/30
Issue Volume: 28

Save Yourself Get ready for a summer without lifeguards.

image: Search and Rescue: Pool owners can’t find enough lifeguards, thanks to new visa laws.

Search and Rescue: Pool owners can’t find enough lifeguards, thanks to new visa laws.
(Darrow Montgomery)

Say you find yourself stuck at the bottom of the deep end this summer, with nobody diving in to drag your increasingly lifeless body to the surface and suck all that community pool water from your lungs. And, as you head to the hereafter, you’re looking for somebody to blame.

Start with Lou Dobbs. But save some hate for American foreign policy and the euro. Oh, and David Hasselhoff.

They’ve all helped make it tough to keep lifeguard chairs full this year.

As the swimming season opened over Memorial Day weekend, area pool managers were facing the most severe lifeguard-supply shortage in memory—perhaps the worst ever, says Amy Kroloff of Century Pools.

“This is definitely the most challenging year I’ve ever seen,” says Kroloff, whose Kensington-based employer manages hundreds of community, apartment, and condo pools on the East Coast and is the biggest such manager in the D.C. market. “I’ve heard it was hard in the 1980s, but I wasn’t around for that. We thought we had the problems figured out.”

At some point during that last drought, Century and other large-scale pool management firms figured out they could no longer depend simply on American butts to fill the lifeguard chairs. Kids here started deciding jobs at the mall were better than those at the pool. And summer school went from a place reserved for unmotivated dirtballs taking remedial English to a hangout for responsible youngsters—good lifeguard stock—looking for college prep.

And, pool folks had to admit, lifeguarding had attained a rather shlocky stigma.

Baywatch didn’t help us, I’ll tell you that,” says Hank Lavery, a pools lifer.

Lavery’s career got going in 1975, when he was 15 years old and took his lifeguarding job at Brinkley Towers, an apartment complex in Oxon Hill. He spent a few decades in pool management in the area and now operates Millennium Pools, a pool-service company based in Northern Virginia.

“This was a great job when I was a kid,” he says. “Everybody wanted to be a lifeguard. But that was when kids had their summers off, no summer school, no internships—when we put our kids in the sun and let them enjoy the summer. Now, we don’t let them in the sun, everybody’s in summer school, and there’s a lot more pools. It’s impossible to keep them all guarded.”

So in the 1990s, Lavery, like other pool managers, began depending on young foreigners, who found the prospect of being an American lifeguard far more intriguing than domestic counterparts. (Hasselhoff, the troubled former Baywatch hunk, was always bigger in Germany than he was here, remember.)

While so many sectors of U.S. industry were outsourcing jobs, the summer recreation field became dependent on foreign labor.

And, by focusing on international hiring efforts, the companies got by. At the end of the last century, Century Pools established an office dedicated to recruiting foreign workers. For the last four years, Kroloff has run that branch of the company’s business.

The jobs gave foreigners an opportunity to make some money, then go back to their homes around the globe full of tales of summer fun like those the Beach Boys used to export to the world.

By 2006, Century was bringing about 1,000 foreign workers into the United States to work at its swimming pools for the season.

But a lot of those folks either aren’t welcome or don’t find lifeguarding in America as dreamy anymore. Kroloff says the company will be lucky to have 600 foreign workers this year.

The most recent and devastating hit to the foreign lifeguard pipeline came courtesy of the anti-immigrant movement in the States, figureheaded by the thinking man’s white supremacist, CNN’s Lou Dobbs.

The H-2B visa, a temporary work visa program that allowed overseas workers to keep our waters safe while summering in America, has been all but killed off. The category was set up by the U.S. State Department to provide workers for seasonal, non-agricultural industries that would be left shorthanded if only domestic labor were available.

There is a quota of 66,000 new H-2B visas each year, but historically returning workers weren’t counted against the current year’s cap. So if companies were able to find a good worker, they could bring him or her back each year.

But the H-2B cap exclusion provision expired in October 2007, and by then it was already caught up in the immigration debate. Lavery started a Web site, savesmallbusiness.org, that served as a clearinghouse for information about the H-2B and lobbied for congressional relief.

But, with Dobbs and others stoking the xenophobic fires night after night after night on national television, there weren’t enough congressmen willing to be seen as pro-foreigner to get the provision renewed. Sen. Barbara Mikulski of Maryland, one of the few vocal H-2B supporters, introduced a measure to extend the cap provision and inserted it into the Iraq War funding bill considered by the Senate. Mikulski’s main concern wasn’t lifeguarding but the seafood industry in her state: For years, most of the folks who pick your crabmeat on the Eastern Shore have been imported Mexicans.

But last week, Mikulski’s amendment was knocked out of the bill. The debate is over. The H-2B program was essentially dead.

“That was our last hope,” says Kroloff.

So, for 2008, a total of 66,000 visas will be issued—a number small enough to make the entire program almost worthless. Century Pools had 300 workers with H-2B visas last year.

This year, it will have none.

Geo Bacharov, a Bulgarian, was among the wide-eyed imports brought here by Century Pools during the salad days of imported lifeguards. He was a guard and manager at several community pools in the region, including Manchester Farms and Churchill Village South in the Germantown area, each summer from 2001 through 2007.

“I liked the U.S. a lot,” writes Bacharov. “I will always feel it part of me.”

A part of his past, that is. My interview with Bacharov was conducted via e-mail from his hometown of Varna, a Bulgarian city of 450,000 on the Black Sea. Despite a fabulous endorsement from his employer, he wasn’t given a visa to return this year.

So the foreign workers on Century Pools roster this year will come via student visas, which, because they allow shorter stays and are reserved only for younger and less experienced lifeguards, aren’t as helpful to employers as the H-2Bs.

And, Kroloff found during her world travels, foreign students are far tougher to come by than they once were. Beyond the visa conundrums, kids from formerly fertile lifeguard turf such as Eastern Europe aren’t as wide-eyed about America since the invasion of Iraq and the brutal beating the U.S. dollar has suffered from just about every foreign currency out there.

And, even with the downturn in the U.S. economy, American kids still aren’t looking to return to lifeguarding.

“So many of the domestic kids we brought in this year couldn’t swim the 300 yards or get bricks off the bottom of the deep end—the Red Cross tests you’ve got to pass to get certified,” says Kroloff. “This could be a real problem.”

Lavery says his 15-year-old daughter just completed the required lifesaving courses and immediately found a job paying $9 an hour lifeguarding in Northern Virginia.

“I used to get $3 an hour,” he says. “If you have any experience, I’ve heard you can make $15. The demand is crazy.”

But while the pool industry picked up Lavery’s daughter, it’s losing an employee, too. On Friday, the day after Mikulski’s amendment was wiped out, Kroloff quit her job at Century.

She says the immigration debate left her “beaten down.” She didn’t leave lightly.

“I’ve been to 50 countries as a proud American, recruited internationals all over the world to bring them here either to work or study and experience our culture,” Kroloff says. “Ironically, my government, my country won’t allow this opportunity, legally, to work and travel, and I’m telling you that the American dream that was so strong even years ago is fading fast. It’s the complete antithesis of public diplomacy.”

Kroloff doesn’t have another job lined up.

Comments

Comment on this article Comment on this Article   Hide Comments Hide Comments (10 comments)
  • TuitonHater May. 29, 2008
    11:24 am

    Actually a few parties to blame: 1) The colleges. They require students to return to campus as early as mid-August while pools/beaches need to be fully staffed until labor day or later 2) The colleges: In addition to uncontrollable tuition inflation, the scam they pull on text book mark up is criminal so kids need higher paying jobs 3) Insurance companies: Require lifeguards to be 18 which ends up excluding most high school kids

  • Kirk Marchand May. 30, 2008
    10:14 am

    I sent an e-mail letter to the editor about this, I worked for Century for 10 summers and I also worked with Hank Lavery. There's another issue at work here. Lifeguards and pool operators are required for training almost on the level of a paramedic, but the pay is not comparable at all. Then there are the increasing liability issues. If lifeguards were getting the $15 to $20 an hour their training warrants, there really wouldn't be a problem. On the other hand, there are community pools that wouldn't be able to afford to stay open. So it's a conundrum.

  • My daughters lifeguarded in the late 90s and early 00s. Yeah, the pay was a problem but spineless bosses who wouldn't stand up for them was the biggest problem.

  • ArgleBargle May. 30, 2008
    7:36 pm

    So if I have this correct it is the governments fault because among other things a.) we won't allow enough foreign workers in AND b.) foreign workers don't want to come here because the Iraq war soured them on America. Alrighty then.

  • Ummm, Mr. Dobbs has an issue with ILLEGAL immigrants, as do many, many Americans. Your delibrate attempt to conflate this with opposition to LEGAL immigration, which is what these lifeguards are, is its own form of bigotry.

    Doing this also demonstrates that you have no way to factually argue with those of us who are against ILLEGAL immigration. Oh, and your labelling Mr. Dobbs (along with those who agree with him) a white supremicist demonstrates this also.

    Those who can not successfully argue their side with facts, resort to name calling and misrepresentation of their opponents views.

  • Mitchell Young May. 31, 2008
    11:19 am

    Hmmm,

    I looked up the inflation rate going back to 1975, the year Mr. Lavery started lifeguarding

    http://www.miseryindex.us/irbyyear.asp

    Then plugged the data into an excel spreadsheat. His $3/hr in 1975 works out to $12.63. Less than the $15 he claims to have seen, but more than the $9/hr his daughter is getting.

    I then looked up the wages at my old employer, the city of laguna nigel -- pool lifeguard. As I recall I earned $7.40 /hr in 1988. That's $12.98/hr today, the top rate they are advertizing ($10.75/13.00). So wages there are keeping pace with inflation, but dont' indicate any shortage.

    A summer camp was advertising for two months work as a lifeguard, $2000 , which doesn't see like a lot for a whole season (yes, room and board was offered, but most college kids can get that at home).

    Former lifeguards are invited to try this at home, its easy these days to find wage data /adverts online. The reporter who stenographed this story might want to run the numbers also.

    Finally, let's face it, part of the problem here is too much immigration. More people, more pools, but a lot of new immigrants and their kids just don't have the water training and really aren't strong swimmers -- they aren't going to be qualified without a lot of 'remedial' work.

  • The shortage of labor in our area is huge. My company runs ads, visits High Schools (if your even allowed in), Colleges/Universities, attends job fairs and we can't get much interest in the kids today to work. I think the parents in America need to teach their kids that having a job is a great learning experience. Learning to deal with people, co-workers, money, etc. The Y generation is always asking the question "Why do I have to work?"; "Why do I have to pay rent and that much?"; Why? - this is going to hurt our country now and in the future. We need to allow people from all over the world to come and work (Legally) in our country. We have the jobs and not enough people to do them or people here that will not do the jobs. It is time to wake up and do something about this problem. Our economy needs the help. I believe this political year is also what is making the H2B returning worker the problem. The pool companies, crabbing industry, ski resorts, beach resorts, National Parks, etc. are all having issues with labor and we need to pay attention!

  • Mitchell Young Jun. 01, 2008
    5:49 am

    J Gromada

    What industry are you in? What starting wages are you offering? What are those wages compaired to 10 , 20 , 30 years ago? How about in 'take home' terms? The answer to a 'shortage' is to increase wages -- if you can't without going out of business, then maybe you shouldn't be in that business. For example, there have been news reports of farmers shifting crops from tomatoes, which take lot of labor, to corn, which doesn't. It is better for the economy overall to have fewer, but more productive workers, than to flood the economy with cheap labor.

    As to the lifeguard issue, I think I've demostrated that wages are sub par. Start paying $20 an hour and I'll be 'those kids today' will come running.

  • Unfortunately most people want to live in the US. When do we stop? When the population is 1 Billion, 2 Billion?

  • I have worked with Amy Kroloff in 2006 in Fairfax,Virginia. She is ok, but Bulgarian supervisors were terrible !!! I am not surprised that she quit. The century pool management did not provide lifeguards with appropriate equipments. Our pool didn't even have an UMBRELLA for lifeguard! And every time when any LG were sitting under the arbor, the supervisors threatened with firing from the pool! We were about 20 Lifeguards FOREIGN but LEGAL students.So we quit this job in two weeks after the arrival to the US. CPM office in my ountry had existed for two years only.

Add a Comment (Link will open a popup window)

Author: Dave McKenna
Author: McKenna
Issue: 2008/05/30
Issue Volume: 28
D.C. Dish Hall of Fame
advertisement
Crafty Bastards Blog
  • Crafty Bastards!
    Blog
Come take a walk

This Week

Current Issue
The Issue of Nov. 18 - 24, 2009

advertisement
advertisement