Young and Hungry

Introducing the “Super” List: Monthly Favorite Beers

Beerscale 001_opt

Several years ago when we were getting more studious about beer, Tammy started carrying around a list from The Brickskiller and checked off and rated each new beer she had. Her first scale, which was unique at best, meaningless at worst, had the following ratings: Super+, Super, Super-, OK++, OK+, OK, OK-, and Yuck. Bruce helped develop a slightly less ridiculous version that went: Superb, Super, Great, Good, Not so Good, and Bad.

Needless to say, a better system was quickly needed. In addition to moving to a pocket Moleskine, Tammy figured out that rating a beer somewhere between "the most amazing thing I've drunk EVER" and "not...terrible" was useless.  Ultimately descriptions of each new brew were what proved helpful anytime we wanted to look back at an entry.

So now we take the time to describe all new beers, but only "rate" a beer if it's really, really good or really, really bad. As a result, the scale has been shrunk to Super and Yuck. Our Jedi beer skills usually help ward off beverages we are likely to find distasteful, so we don't come across Yucks that often. But our passion for beer has us drinking a lot of it and we consistently find brews worthy of the coveted Super rating.

We have decided to start sharing our "Super" List with you, in monthly installments. We think we can have some fun with this and hope to hear about what beers would be on your Super and Yuck lists. It should also be an interesting exercise in seeing where our beer biases lie, and how our palates change over time. You can look for last month's Super List on Monday. In the meantime, enjoy the weekend.


  1. #1

    I was just about to ask for your top five Supers and bottom five Yucks? Then I read I have to wait til Monday.

    How about a teaser? I did a top five for the month of January, with Oskar Blues Ten FIDY coming in first. What about you guys?

Leave a Comment

Blogs Linking to this Article

  1. The Super List: January 2010 vs. 2007 - Young & Hungry - Washington City Paper

    [...] Friday we introduced our new series, The Super List. Each month we will be sharing the beers that Tammy, in true elementary school [...]

  2. The Super List: February 2010 - Young & Hungry - Washington City Paper

    [...] those who missed the list for January or our introduction to the series, we’ll start with a quick catch-up on what the Super List is. In a nutshell, we like beer and [...]

  3. The Super List: Beers to Try This Summer - Young & Hungry

    [...] the only thing you can do. I keep track of all the suds I consume and from time to time offer a "Super List" of the ones I feel are worth checking out. Here is a short list of summer [...]

Comments Shown. Turn Comments Off.