The Sexist

How D.C. Hospitals Fail Trans Patients

WHC-1

Two years ago, Roberta, a 59-year-old Arlington County resident, reported to Virginia Hospital Center for a breast-cancer screening. “There’s a man here to have a mammogram!” a clinician announced across the room when she arrived for her appointment.

Roberta is not a man—she’s a transgender woman who began publicly transitioning from male to female six years ago. And like any woman, she requires regular mammograms for the breasts she developed through hormone therapy. “Technically, they know what they’re doing, and they’re really, really good,” Roberta says of the hospital’s staff. But when it comes to treating transgender patients with care, “they’re clueless.”

Last month, the Human Rights Campaign released its 2010 Healthcare Equality Index in an attempt at providing healthcare providers a clue. The report surveyed 16 Washington-area hospitals on their patient anti-discrimination policies, looking for explicit mentions of sexual orientation and gender identity. While eight local hospitals’ policies explicitly recognize the rights of gay, lesbian, and bisexual patients, none mention gender identity or expression—in other words, a commitment to respecting patients like Roberta.

Which means going to the hospital—rarely a particularly pleasant experience—often produces an overlay of uncertainty and anxiety for transgender patients. Without a firm policy in place, the care transgender patients receive often comes down to chance; a caregiver who’s familiar with transgender issues may treat patients perfectly fine, but if they encounter the wrong employee, problems can ensue. Even, sometimes, within the same hospital.

Take the case of Washington Hospital Center, one of the local hospitals to include sexual orientation—but not gender identity—in its nondiscrimination policy. Last October, Stacey Roberts cut open her left pointer finger while slicing fruit. So she headed to the District hospital’s emergency room, where she received a bandage from a nurse—and a transphobic attitude at check-out. The employee who completed Roberts’ hospital visit “repeatedly insisted on calling me ‘sir,’” she says. “For each question he asked me, he blatantly added the term ‘sir’ at the end.”

Roberts—who says she was “dressed very feminine, in a dress”—listened to the man address her as the incorrect gender half a dozen times before requesting that he modify his language. “I didn’t even ask him to call me by feminine pronouns,” says Roberts. “I just asked him to stop gratuitously calling me sir.” The employee refused. Though Roberts identifies as female, and began presenting a feminine gender expression years ago, she has yet to secure a legal name and gender change. And until the government officially recognizes Roberts as a woman, the clerk claimed, he’s “legally required” to treat Roberts as the gender listed on her identifying documents. (That’s news to local LGBT activists.)

That same month, another District transgender woman checked into Washington Hospital Center following a suicide attempt. After swallowing “a lot of pills,” she was rushed by friends to the hospital, where she spent several days in the mental-health ward. “I’ve had really negative experiences at other hospitals in the area,” says the woman. So once she regained consciousness at Washington Hospital Center, “I was really surprised—pleasantly surprised—that everyone was super-respectful.” The woman says hospital staff had “no problem” identifying her as female and providing her trans-specific healthcare throughout her stay. Despite the mental-health ward’s highly regimented routine, “they let me go to the bathroom at certain times on my own to deal with trans-related stuff,” says the 31-year-old, who asked to remain anonymous due to the nature of her treatment. Staff was also quick to prescribe the hormone medication she takes daily. “The treatment I got there was really important,” she says. “If I’d had a negative experience there, it would have made everything a lot worse.”

Those two wildly different experiences stem from a hospital with a confused LGBT anti-discrimination policy. According to a Washington Hospital Center representative, the institution “has long observed a broad policy of nondiscrimination and is committed to providing care to all those with an emergent need, without regard to any status protected by law.” But once the policy gets into specifics, it reveals a fundamental misunderstanding of the LGBT community. “With respect to Washington Hospital Center’s nondiscrimination policy, we are in the process of revising it to enhance our current reference to sexual orientation to include the more specific reference to gender identity or expression,” the hospital said in a statement, adding that “staff education will accompany implementation to ensure all patients are treated in a sensitive manner.”

Except gender identity or expression is not a “more specific” reference to sexual orientation. Roberts, for example, is a transgender woman who also happens to be a lesbian—and those two identities are not one and the same.

In a few weeks, Washington Hospital Center’s policies will, technically, be in compliance with the HRC’s expectations. “In the Healthcare Equality Index survey, we asked for specific language—explicit language that policies were inclusive of LGBT families,” says Tom Sullivan, deputy director for the Human Rights Campaign Family Project. But improved written policies might not translate into actual improvements in care. “I don’t think there’s a correlation between having protections for gender identity and actually providing trans-specific and trans-friendly healthcare,” says a local man who prefers the term “trans” to “transgender,” and has had several negative experiences at local hospitals.

A couple of years ago, the 20-something—who wished to remain anonymous—sought treatment at Sibley Memorial Hospital for possible appendicitis. When he arrived, he disclosed his trans status to his doctor for medical reasons. “I explained to the doctor that I’m FTM and what that means,” he says. “She had no clue what was going on. It’s one thing to not know about trans-specific healthcare, but it’s another to be so ignorant that you say things that are medically impossible. She asked me when I had my uterus implanted.” Other hospital personnel expressed disbelief that the bearded man standing before them was trans. “People were just visibly shocked,” he says. “And they were open about that shock. They said, ‘Oh my god. Really?’ In a medical situation where you’re disclosing all kinds of information, that’s not a response that’s ever appropriate.”

Sibley maintains that it has policies on the books meant to protect transgender patients against such affronts. Sheliah Roy, director of public relations and marketing for the hospital, notes that its patients’ bill of rights includes the right to “receive hospital services without discrimination on the basis of any factor to which discrimination is prohibited by law.” Because discrimination based on gender identity has been prohibited in D.C. since 2007, Sibley’s policy technically covers transgender patients. Transgender patients at hospitals in Maryland and Virginia don’t benefit from similar legal protections.

“Every time I go to the hospital,” Roberta says, “I have to give ‘Trans 101’ to everyone I meet.” Unless hospitals write coherent guidelines and provide training on their own, that responsibility may keep falling on patients.

Photo by Darrow Montgomery

  • DStreet

    I'm glad the 31-year-old was treated well, but letting someone who has just attempted suicide have privacy in the bathroom is actually pretty irresponsible. If something had happened, we would have been commenting on how the hospital employees didn't take proper care because the patient was trans

  • JR

    Thanks for writing this! I'm a 30 year old trans man and I am afraid whenever I get sick and can't see my regular doc or have to go to the hospital. There are so many areas that are fear inducing in everyday life, that most people take for granted. I recently had to come out (a number of times) at the neighborhood swimming pool because they have a "no t-shirt" policy for men, and nothing on the books about pre-op transmen.

  • Eli

    "And until the government officially recognizes Roberts as a woman, the clerk claimed, he’s “legally required” to treat Roberts as the gender listed on her identifying documents."
    The opposite, in fact. District of Columbia law states that repeatedly using the incorrect pronouns is considered harrassment and discrimination....which is illegal.

  • kza

    Instead of making more and more policy can't they just hire people who aren't assholes?

  • bellacoker

    Kza: It seems those people are harder to find than one would think, esp. in some fields like medicine.

  • Stacey

    Sad thing is... Washington Hospital Center is the only hospital in DC that has medical staff trained for rape kit examinations and evidence collection. ... not having properly trained staff nor understanding the difference between Sexual Orientation and Gender Identity creates a chilling effect for the trans-community.

    Eli - That's what I informed the clerk. He wouldn't have it.

  • Brianw8

    Whenever a customer walks into the store where I work, I usually try to address them in a gender-neutral way.

  • Brianw8

    This is one reason why people need to be educated on the difference between gender and sex, gender expression/identity and sexual orientation.

  • Brianw8

    Whenever a customer walks into the store where I work, I usually try to address them in a gender-neutral way. Sometimes, I will say ma'am or sir if they are in attire typical of a particular gender/sex. If I cannot make a distinction, I just usually say something like, "Hello, how are you today?"

  • http://www.sldmodels.co.uk Sarah

    I think our treatment by certain people is absolutely disgusting you know, but I think that a lot of campaigners trying to get us our equal rights are forgetting some very simple things.

    In the UK, we have the NHS which is government run so, the government has to be seen to be above making moral judgements about patients, and when an individual doesn't treat you right, you can make complaints.

    In the US, where most of your healthcare is privately funded, you are a paying customer and you can choose to take your healthcare money elsewhere. Admittedely, you'd probably be seen in by the same people in the same hospitals, but you can complain to your healthcare provider, tell them you're not happy, and if they don't do something about it, you'll take your custom elsewhere, possibly take legal action against the hospital concerned.

    Regardless of whether the medical people respect us or not, they chose to do the job they did to help other people, and therefore they can only do a good job if the people they treat leave in a better condition than they we're when they came in.

    I'm not surprised the mental health ward treated the patient better though, as they have to be more considerate of people to do their job nowadays.

  • Elizabeth K

    As a 63 year old diagnosed MTF - and in transition, I had an episode of suicide attempts. About a year ago I was in the hospital emergency room for detoxification - which required having to run the usual gauntlet of admission and medical history questions. It was a very good hospital, set in a population area of about 35,000 collecively - and I doubt they had ever encountered a transperson in the ER. I was a curiosity to say the least as I had to 'out' in detail my condition to seven people 'officially." What was interesting is the number of people who suddenly found it necessary to come into the exam room to remove the waste basket, restock shelves, and the like. We are an attraction. Of course within two weeks I was known as transexual all through the small town I was living . I was rather androgynous at the time and gender neutral in clothing, so I suspect the 'man in a dress' expectations were squelched. Professonally I had no mistreatment, but behind it was the unprofessionalism of outing me to the community. That seems to be the way of the world.

    Lizzy

  • Pingback: Transgender patients discuss healthcare at D.C. hospitals - The Sexist - Washington City Paper

  • Pingback: Weekend Link Love « The Feminist Texican

...