Housing Complex

District Lawyers: If Judge Bans Use of Rec Centers as Shelter, City Can’t Comply

The Benning Park Recreation Center, where homeless families have complained of poor conditions.

The Benning Park Recreation Center, where homeless families have complained of poor conditions.

The District will have no adequate place to shelter homeless families if a judge orders it to stop the controversial use of recreation centers as severe-weather shelters, city lawyers argued in court today.

Appearing before D.C. Superior Court Judge Robert D. Okun for the second consecutive day, the District's attorneys continued to argue against the assertion by a group of homeless families and their lawyers that the use of the rec centers violates the D.C. law requiring the city to house families in apartment-style shelters or private rooms when temperatures with windchill drop below freezing. With arguments running until the court's closing time, Okun did not issue a ruling, but will return Monday morning to do so.

Today's hearing was the result of an inconclusive ruling yesterday, in which Okun agreed to turn the case into a class-action suit—previously, a judge issued a temporary restraining order against the use of shelters, but only for the four families listed as plaintiffs—but found that the homeless families' attorneys had not provided sufficient evidence that sleeping in rec centers posed a danger of irreparable harm, a necessary ingredient for the preliminary injunction against the use of rec centers that the plaintiffs sought. The plaintiffs returned today with four witnesses, three people who have stayed at rec centers and one expert witness, to testify on the conditions at the rec centers and the harm they cause.

But the debate then pivoted to the options available to the District should Okun ban the use of rec centers—a discussion on which the ultimate ruling could hinge. District lawyer Kim Katzenbarger argued that with the city's traditional shelters full, and no more rooms available in the hotels to which the city has turned to as overflow shelters, the city would be unable to comply with an injunction.

"If you order this relief, the District will not be able to comply," Katzenbarger said. "The District is simply out of space."

She added, "If the court orders this, the District will probably be found in contempt."

Katzenbarger said that if the city did locate space, possibly at a school or another public building, it would still have to use the cots and partitions to which the families have objected at the rec centers.

The attorneys for the homeless families countered that it is in the city's ability to locate space. Allison Holt, of the law firm Hogan Lovells, mentioned the former Hebrew Home for the Aged on Spring Road NW, which has long been vacant and was recently mentioned by Department of Human Services Director David Berns as a possible site for permanent supportive housing for formerly homeless residents. Michele Williams, who oversees DHS' homeless services, confirmed today that the site is under consideration for other uses, leading Holt to argue that it could just as easily be used as emergency shelter.

"It's disingenuous to say there are no other public buildings when they're being considered for other purposes," Holt argued.

The plaintiffs' witnesses laid out a litany of complaints about the conditions at the rec centers that might constitute irreparable harm. Dalanda Griffin, who stayed earlier this week at the Benning Park Recreation Center with her husband and three children, testified that her son with severe asthma was unable to use his plug-in nebulizer in the partitioned sleeping space. She said she didn't take her children to school on Wednesday because they had wet the bed and smelled like urine, and there were no showers available in the rec center for them to clean themselves. She opted to leave Benning Park and spend the next night in the hallway of an apartment building two blocks away "because we got privacy."

Jenique Fultz, appearing on the witness stand with her week-old daughter, said that when she applied for shelter on Wednesday, she mentioned that she had given birth five days earlier and requested special treatment, but was still placed at Benning Park. There, she says, she stayed up all night "for the safety of my child and myself."

The expert witness, Danielle Rothman, who holds a master's degree in clinical psychology and works with homeless children at the Homeless Children's Playtime Project, testified that the lack of sleep at the rec centers could lead children to have trouble concentrating and fall behind in school. She also said that the fear they experience at the rec centers can cause "learned helplessness," in which their inability to obtain privacy or safety can lead them to fall into dangerous situations later in childhood and adolescence.

"These harms are irreparable for the children that face them," Holt argued in conclusion. "There are no money damages that could put those children back in a place of security."

The plaintiffs had hoped for a ruling today, given that hypothermic conditions are forecast for Sunday night, meaning families will be returning to the rec centers. But Okun was unable to conclude the hearing in time. On Monday, he'll issue a ruling on the preliminary injunction, either requiring the city to cease housing any homeless families in the current rec-center conditions or allowing the practice to continue as long as the chilly weather persists.

Image via Google Maps

  • Ward-8

    This is one of the most asinine suits I have seen, here you have people who don't have a pot to pis in or window to throw it out and in all probability would have been sleeping on the streets with no privacy, no food, no bathroom, no heat or bed had it not been for the generosity of the DC Government, yet they demand that the District providing all of this free services not put them in places where they don't have privacy. Give me a freaking break, you want privacy,food and shelter, stop bitching and get your own place or don't accept the freebie.

  • drez

    Hypothermia season is almost over. This latest is a stall for time. Soon it becomes the next administration's problem.

  • Pingback: District Lawyers: If Judge Bans Use of Rec Centers as Shelter, City Can’t Comply | NextOff

  • Corky

    This makes me sick that the city may end up paying some massive legal fees because it enacted a stupid law that these choosey, ungrateful beggars are taking advantage of. Get a damn job and stop having kids you can't afford if you want privacy. A rec center is more than enough if the alternative is sleeping on a park bench. And somebody needs to lock up that silly psychologist for embarrassing the mental health profession with her ridiculous opinions.

  • Pingback: Ron Machen feels the heat

  • Pingback: Judge Orders D.C. to Stop Sheltering Homeless Families at Rec Centers - Housing Complex

  • Typical DC BS

    Funny how DC residents fail to see the irony in this situation.

  • jasmine yurly

    I FIND IT STRANGE THAT THE GOVERMENT HAVE MONEY FOR OTHER COUNTRIES AND WARS BUT CANT TAKE CARE OF HOME YET THE COST OF LIVING IS SKY DIVING AND I HAVE A GREAT PAYING JOB BUT AM ONE CHECK AWAY FROM BEING HOMELESS CITY COUNCIL NEED TO STOP STEALING TAX PAYERS DOLLARS AND HELP THESE FAMILIES BEFORE IT BEGAN TO AFFECT OUR STREETS THAT THEY CARE SO MUCH ABOUT REMODELING BE SERIOUS IT CAN BE U OR UR LOVED ONES ONE DAY WITH NO HELP OR NOONE TO TURN TO WHERE ARE UR TAX DOLLARS REALLY GOING NOT TO THE COMMUNITY I CAN ASSURE U

  • http://imgur.com/5M6m1pq http://imgur.com/5M6m1pq

    I was suggested this blog by my cousin. I am not sure whether this post is
    written by him as nobody else know such detailed about my trouble.
    You are incredible! Thanks!

    Here is my weblog Castle Clash Hack (http://imgur.com/5M6m1pq)

  • http://www.gameinformer.com/blogs/members/b/dylanbarlow_blog/archive/2014/04/28/csr-classics-hack-android-ios.aspx Abbie

    What's up to all, it's truly a fastidious for me to go to see this site, it contains valuable Information.

    Feel free to visit my homepage :: CSR Clasics Hack Download (Abbie)

  • Pingback: blue ofica

...