Housing Complex

Gretchen Pfaehler to Chair Historic Preservation Review Board

Pfaehler at the October 25 HPRB hearing

Historic Preservation Review Board chair Catherine Buell is stepping down to lead a city development project and will be replaced by HPRB member Gretchen Pfaehler.

Buell was appointed to the board in 2008 and became the first female HPRB chair in 2010. After two and a half years, she's leaving both HPRB and her paying job as an attorney at the law firm Patton Boggs (HPRB members receive just a nominal stipend) to oversee the development of the St. Elizabeths East Campus in Ward 8, where she resides. She begins her work at the office of the Deputy Mayor for Planning and Economic Development on Monday.

Pfaehler is a relative newcomer to HPRB, having just been appointed to the board in April, but she's no stranger to historic preservation: She worked on preservation review boards in Madison, Wis., and Ann Arbor, Mich. She's also no stranger to the District, having lived here for 15 years. And she serves as director of preservation at an international engineering and consulting firm, the Michael Baker Corporation.

When it comes to historic preservation, there's always something of a tug-of-war between pro-development people who want preservation to be incorporated into a changing city and anti-development people who seek to use preservation as a tool to prevent changes. Most HPRB members, of course, fall somewhere in the middle. Buell's predecessor, Tersh Boasberg, was an imposing force in the field, a 10-year chair who wrote several books about preservation and headed just about every relevant body in the city; he was considered something of a conservative. Buell sought to bring a bit more flexibility to preservation and to "keep preservation relevant and cool."

So where does Pfaehler fit into the spectrum? She's studiously neutral in a phone interview.

"I think there’s always a tradeoff," says the Capitol Hill resident, who previously lived on the Southwest Waterfront. "We’re not keeping the District as a museum. It’s a functioning international and global political city." She believes that preservation should be wielded in such a way as to allow for "development and sustainability and creating a walkable smart-growth city."

However, a case that came before HPRB in May indicates that Pfaehler may be critical of sustainability if it comes at the expense of longstanding aesthetics. The case concerned a homeowner in the historic district of Cleveland Park who wanted to install rooftop solar panels. The initial HPRB vote was a 4-4 tie, with Buell voting to allow the panels and Pfaehler voting not to allow them. Buell, as chair, then abstained to allow for a conclusive vote, and the solar panels were rejected.

"I don’t think that sustainability and preservation are mutually exclusive," Pfaehler says. "I think it’s imprtant to look at sustainability as part of a larger spectrum." Speaking specifically of solar panels, she adds, "We need to make sure they’re integreated in a way that’s responsible."

Pfaehler believes she's taking over at a particularly important juncture for the city's preservation efforts. "I’m excited by the challenge that’s coming with some large projects in the District," she says. "I think about St. Elizabethss and the potential of what could happen in that community. And I think about places like the McMillan Reservoir and Walter Reed. There’s some interesting projects that have a larger influence."

Pfaehler says she isn't sure when the announcement of her appointment will be made publicly, nor does she know when she'll officially take over as chair. Tanya Washington, chief of staff at the Office of Planning, which oversees HPRB, tells me, "We expect the new chair of HPRB to be named in time for the Dec. 20 meeting."

Comments

  1. #1

    Another awful NIMBY. Thanks Mayor Gray!

    Unless it's an existing old building, HPRB should have no purview. A new building built in a historic district should not be "modified" / bastardized by such a board to make it vaguely mimic historic buildings while still looking as out of place as another modern building.

  2. #2

    RT- you have no idea what you're talking about.
    Just admit it.
    Why in hell would you jump out in front with a lede that says she's a NIMBY? Give her a month or two at the job before going on the attack. Okay?
    Complain all you want about the role of HPRB, but the simple fact is that they do and should have purview over new buildings in historic districts. Try and change the law if you think it's wrong, but don't attack this woman for doing a pretty thankless job. Or, better yet, RT, get on the board and help make the decisions that you slam.
    As to your claim that the new buildings must vaguely mimic historic structures, please walk down 14th St.
    There are many a new structure, approved by the very HPRB you rail against. None of them mimic the historic buildings in the neighborhood. I wish they did, but they don't. You should be pleased with what's being built.
    Why start by calling someone names that are meaningless?
    If you want to have a rational discussion about contextual architecture, bring in on.
    But to get so hysterical before the holidays is a bit too much for all of us.
    Relax, go shopping along 14th, and see there's contemporary design being approved by HPRB up and down the avenue.
    And, please, make a resolution for the new year that includes not being nasty in your comments. Keep 'em civil.
    It'll reflect better on the point you're trying to make, tone down the negativity that seems to accepted as discourse here in DC, and take the edge off your life.
    You'll be happier, too.

  3. #3

    "keeing" "St. Elizabethss" - just a couple things caught by your friendly neighborhood editor :)

  4. #4

    hi and thanks regarding the certain post ive really been looking regarding this kind of information online for sum time these days hence thanks a whole lot.

  5. #5

    ? Salut et merci concernant le certain poste ive vraiment été à la recherche en ce qui concerne ce genre d'information en ligne pour le temps de la somme de ces jours où grâce un tas

  6. #6

    Oferta de Polo Ralph Lauren en nuestro Ralph Lauren salida online.We le puede ofrecer una variedad de hombres Polo Ralph Lauren, Burberry Polo Camisas mujer, precios bajos, productos de calidad y con envío gratis.

  7. #7

    . Savez-vous que votre site charges peu étranges dans Internet Explorer 7 ? Certains des bords sont coupés . Article génial indépendamment .

  8. #8

    ? Tengo curiosidad por localizar lo weblog plataforma que se esté empleando Estoy teniendo algunos problemas menores de seguridad con mi último blog, y me gustaría encontrar algo mucho más libre de riesgo. ¿Usted puede ser que tenga alguna sugerencia

  9. #9

    Ahora la pareja está a punto de casarse, mientras que Goodwin sonríe valientemente desde la banca con dolor, anhelo no correspondido y tiene lágrimas.

Leave a Comment

Comments Shown. Turn Comments Off.
...