Housing Complex

Jason Chaffetz Will Not Be Our Overlord–But the New Guy Might be Worse

Brian Bilbray, D.C.'s new Congressional overseer. (Brian Bilbray's flickr stream)

UPDATE, 1:30 p.m. - Whoops: Mike DeBonis is reporting that Bilbray's been removed from the Oversight Committee, which means we don't know who'll be in charge of the District's fate come January.


The GOP golden boy, a favorite of new Oversight and Government Reform Committee chairman Darrell Issa, proved too ambitious for the grunt assignment of overseeing D.C.–last Friday, Jason Chaffetz landed the higher-prestige subcommittee that oversees the Department of Homeland Security. According to Dave Weigel, the House Committee on the District of Columbia will likely be helmed by Rep. Brian Bilbray, who has represented the 50th District of California since 1994 (with a break from 2001 to 2006).

Should D.C. residents feel better about this?

On the plus side: While the 50th District doesn't encompass the city of San Diego, it's decidedly more urban than Chaffetz' domain, which means that Bilbray might have a better understanding of the issues cities face. Bilbray also prides himself on his environmental record, which means he may be supportive of things like efforts to clean up the Anacostia, and perhaps even push the feds to pay their stormwater fees.

But on issues of District autonomy, the signs are not good. Bilbray voted to ban banning needle exchange and medical marijuana in D.C., and cosponsored legislation that would have repealed a raft of restrictions on gun ownership in D.C., before the Supreme Court did it for him.

As far as his philosophy on Congress' relationship with the District, we have some remarks from a hearing back in September on legislative autonomy for D.C. Perhaps because he was gone from D.C. during its turnaround years, he still seems to think of the District as a crime-ridden reservation that still needs Congressional parenting, and was even "appalled" that District residents would have the gall to oppose freeways being rammed through their neighborhoods. In his questioning of D.C. Appleseed director Walter Smith, Bilbray said:

This is my chance to say something about this. I was absolutely appalled when I came here in the 1990's and saw what appeared to be the gross abuses of local control by the local community. Freeways were not allowed to go through because of Ward politics. Maybe it is because I am a Californian that I can't comprehend the ability of politics to stop a freeway dead in its tracks, not just once but twice. Though, I have seen it happen.

The other thing I have just got to tell you is, Mr. Smith, that this District was created for a special reason. This little area between the Anacostia and the Potomac called Turkey Buzzard Point was chosen to be a no man's land from political influences from the outside or from within, much like we do with our military reservations, too.

But I see the effect of the lack of appropriate control of the jurisdiction. I have staffers who resign and go home because they have been attacked, they have been threatened, or they have almost been murdered. I am constantly reminded as a former local government official that the Constitution does give us the ability to authorize jurisdiction but not responsibility. The Constitution still lays that right in our lap. This is one of those things that Congress can't say is out of its jurisdiction. The big difference is that the same Constitution that gives States that jurisdiction–and the States are the ones that give cities their local control, not the Constitution. The Constitution does not take away that local control from other cities. It did in this one, in this city.

So there is an issue here of the appropriateness of authorizing jurisdiction and thinking we can walk away from the
ultimate responsibility of young ladies being attacked, roads not being completed, the congestion, and everything else that is our responsibility.

Oh, also he wants to make sure everyone knows that "no taxation without representation" isn't a Constitutional issue. More from the hearing:

Mr. Bilbray. I would just like to give the Mayor the chance to clarify because I don't think he wants to leave here leaving the impression of a statement he made. I think he misspoke and you don't want to read about it later. You made a reference to "no taxation without representation'' being in the Constitution. Do you want to clarify that you did not mean that clause is in the Constitution?
Mayor Fenty. Well, as you are well aware, Congressman, our country was founded upon the principle that citizens of the country would not be taxed without having—
Mr. Bilbray. Mr. Mayor, I just wanted you to clarify the record that you didn't mean the Constitution.
Mayor Fenty. Point well taken.
Mr. Bilbray. You meant it was basically a–
Mayor Fenty. Point well-taken.
Mr. Bilbray. OK. Thank you. I just wanted to make sure we get on that so you don't–
Mr. Lynch. The gentleman is still recognized for 5 minutes.
Mr. Bilbray. Thank you. I appreciate that.

Whew, sounds like a winner! Alright D.C., you're in for a fun two years (at least).

  • DCDem

    Is the GOP Congress prepared to excuse D.C. residents from having to pay federal taxes? Without representation, what ensures that the will of the citizens of the District who pay federal taxes are having their voice heard, and respected, in Congress?

    It is not a constitutional arguement, it is a matter of getting what we pay for.

  • http://distcurm.blogspot.com/ IMGoph

    can't WAIT for I-95 to be built through takoma and brookland.

    i'd love for you to follow up with the congressman and find out exactly which of DC's many canceled freeways he wants built.

  • http://twitter.com/kcivey KCinDC

    The language stripping DC of its ability to pass most gun laws goes much further than the Heller decision by the Supreme Court. Even Scalia said that some forms of local regulation were constitutional, but the legislation that's been floating around Congress and has passed both the House and the Senate (but fortunately not at the same time) would prevent DC from passing gun laws that are constitutional and that states and other cities would be allowed to pass.

  • RT

    I think we need to fight these guys and use language more suited to their neandethal sensibilities. It's time to picket the Capitol, shut down the roads with MPD vehicles. Civil disobedience is the only way to bring attention to this tyrrany. It's ironic that Republicans- supposed guardians of freedom and "states rights"- are so intent on trampling on the rights and will of a small group of people who pay a lot to get nothing at all. Let's face it. If the District were a Red State, Glenn Beck would be here crying on the Capitol steps demanding action.

  • RT

    Sorry - "neanderthal"

  • deeceefooodeee

    RT - if the majority of MPD officers lived in DC maybe that would work, but most of them don't so they could care less.

  • DCexpat

    Actually his comments on crime seem spot on. And whether we like it or not, he is interpreting the constitution more correctly than our harebrained DC leadership does. If you want representation, move to MD or VA. If you lived in Canada, would you gripe about your lack of US representation? But we know DC is a special place where logic need not apply, and we see the consequences of that everywhere: ignorant, short-lived, murderous thieving fools. And a crackhead councilman ex-mayor. Frankly, you gotta love it and learn to laugh at it, and get in on the underage prostitution action, the greatest industry of the DC ignorant.

  • Kurt

    Bilbray's not on the committee anymore so this piece is moot.

  • Ashley

    DCexpat, you make no sense. Of course if you live in Canada you don't expect representation, because you aren't a US citizen, but last time I checked, those living in DC are US citizens, many even work for the US government, thus it is your logic that is flawed.

  • DCexpat

    Oh yeah? Who will you be voting for for Senator next time around? Exactly.

  • Adam

    @DCexpat - I fail to see how your comparison to Canada is relevant or valid. How can you compare the lack of representation for U.S. citizens living in our nation's capital who pay federal taxes to a lack of U.S. representation for citizens of another country?

  • DCexpat

    Because in terms of federal representation the consitution accords both Canada and DC roughly the same rights. Actually Canada may have more since they can have an ambassador. Go ahead, yell at me if it makes you feel better. It won't change the shitpot of a city I see out my window every day.

  • Indeed

    Somebody beat DCexpat with a stupid stick.

  • poopieface

    Just change the gun laws already.

  • LTO

    I'm an Arlington expat in San Diego. While Bilbray is undoubtedly bad, he's never in his entire career faced competent opposition. He's lazy and he's dumb, and there should be plenty of opportunities to roll him.

  • http://wwwtripwithinthebeltway.blogspot.com/ Douglas A. Willinger

    The congressman should know about the political nonsense surrounding the cancellation of the freeways- and that far far fewer residences would be displaced them commonly assumed.




  • Skipper

    Seems as if DeBonis just schooled LDP on doing things like, you know, research before writing a story.

  • http://www.onlyjav.com オロビアンコ アウトレット

    My brother suggested I might like this website. He used to be totally right. This post actually made my day. You cann't consider just how a lot time I had spent for this information! Thanks!|
    オロビアンコ アウトレット http://www.onlyjav.com