City Desk

District Settles 2000 Mass Arrest Case For $13.7 Million

Within 20 minutes of a hearing in federal court this afternoon, the District and plaintiffs attorneys settled a class-action lawsuit stemming from mass arrests and a police raid during the April 2000 anti-globalization protests—two years before the mass arrests at Pershing Park. This suit involves roughly 600 people arrested. The District agreed to a record $13.7 million payout.

“We are pleased with the settlement," says plaintiffs lawyer Carl Messineo. "It’s a historic settlement and it’s actually a fair deal for the District."

Legal Times reported this may be the largest payout in the U.S. for wrongfully arrested protesters. The two Pershing Park cases are still pending; AG Peter Nickles has promised to settle those lawsuits by Thanksgiving.

The case, Becker vs. D.C., revolved around wrongful arrests during the the anti-globalization demonstrations as well as the controversial police raid on the convergence center where groups were making gazpacho—not bombs or pepper spray as the police officials complained.

The Becker case also included individuals who had sat in a street already closed by D.C. Police. They had linked arms in such a way rendering them useless. D.C. cops had charged at them and beat them with batons. The activists suffered broken noses and head wounds as a result.

Messineo recalls the scene he uncovered through the lawsuit: "A [police official] shouted 'let’s do it!' and the officers charged off the bus, their badges and nameplates removed. They took the batons and smashed them into the faces of people who’s arms were immobilized. They suffered broken noses, broken teeth."

Like the Pershing Park cases, Messineo says, the Becker case had serious discovery problems.

He adds that as part of the monetary settlement, the District agreed to train all of its officers on the proper way to police demonstrations within 120 days of the settlement's approval. The city also agreed to attach a D.C. police officer to any outside agencies that are policing protests in the District. The liaison would ensure that the outside force complies with city law, specifically the bill developed as a result of the Pershing Park controversy—the First Amendment Rights and Police Standards Act of 2004.

The Office of Police Complaints had recently filed a report concerning police actions during demonstrations and found that outside agencies could still be a problem. The complaints board stated in a press release:

"PCB is concerned, however, about action taken by federal law enforcement officers who assisted MPD.  Because the Act does not apply to federal officers, they handle demonstrations differently from MPD, even when assisting with protests on District-controlled public space.  PCB believes this double standard has the potential to undermine accomplishment of the goals of the First Amendment Assemblies Act.

Based on its review of the April 2009 demonstration, PCB recommends that the District, through the combined efforts of the Mayor, the DC Council and the MPD Chief, seek to obtain federal law enforcement agencies’ voluntary compliance with the First Amendment Assemblies Act when assisting MPD officers with protests on District-controlled public space."

Blog Widget by LinkWithin
  • WaPoster

    Ah, the Ramsey legacy. Hope someone sent this along to the Philly papers! Also hope they aren't expecting much for whatever it is they are paying him.

  • Skipper

    When does Ramsey get prosecuted for perjury?

  • Truth hurts

    So does this mean the MPD will have to consider whether there's probable cause before protesters are arrested in the future?

  • Dave McKenna

    god's work, jc. nicely done...

  • downtown rez


  • Rick Mangus

    Don't break out the party hats, guess who will have to pay for this mistake?, you and me.

  • Comrade Al Gonzales

    The DC pigs don't give a shit - it ain't their fucking money. Unless you criminally prosecute Ramsey & the officers described above, nothing will change. Oh & they could also deduct the $13.7 million from the pigs' paychecks. Without criminal prosecutions, nothing will change. Most of these pigs would gladly pay a few thousand bucks to beat the shit out of some hippies.

    Look for more police riots next time there's a demonstration by the Left. Pigs are pigs, & this verdict won't change them at all.

  • Comrade Al Gonzales

    Most of the DC pigs live in MD or VA, so they don't have to pay one cent of this. Only prosecuting & imprisoning rogue police criminals will have any effect. Nothing will change unless & until you do that.

    Ramsey lives in PA & will pay not one cent of this. DC pigs live in VA & MD & pay no taxes in DC, so they won't pay one cent of this.Ramsey is still pulling down his multi-million dollar pension paid by DC.

    So, in the words of Charles Ramsey, fuck you DC punks, it's no sweat off my balls. Fucking pussies.

  • Jason Cherkis

    Actually, D.C. Police will not be paying a dime. The settlement will come from a separate fund in the District budget.

  • downtown rez

    God help me, I agree with Mad Al. This city gets screwed day in and day out by immoral carpet bagging government workers. On both the Federal and Municipal side.
    At least it's only for 13 million and change.
    Not good, but compared to H. Walters, M. Barry, or DC's 3 billion budget, not too horrible either.

  • ArlingtonAaron

    Good on the 2000 protesters for finally getting their due, and getting the concessions on training and liaisons as well. Now we'll see if Nickles has finally figured out how screwed he is on the Pershing case and will agree to the appropriate figure before T-day.

    If this settlement is a record, it won't stand for long I reckon. Maybe the council having to find another 50 Mil+ in next years budget will get them to at least find the time to bother doing hearings on the discovery abuses in the AG's office?

  • Jan Y

    Cool, real cool. I'm real glad for the 2000 protesters, and it's so terrific that they had put up a fight against injustice and won!

  • Pingback: Poll Puts Gray Over Fenty In 2010: Loose Lips Daily - City Desk - Washington City Paper

  • Pingback: What Is The Worst WaPo Editorial Ever? - City Desk - Washington City Paper



  • Pingback: Breaking: District Settles Pershing Park Case - City Desk - Washington City Paper