City Desk

Pershing Park Case: Nickles Attempts To Prevent Detective From Testifying

Last Friday, Pershing Park case lawyers had arranged to depose  Detective Paul Hustler. All was going according to routine. Hustler showed up. The OAG lawyers showed up. The day before, he had been prepped by the OAG's team.  But just as the deposition was about to start, Hustler made an unusual request.

Hustler wanted his own attorney present.

The deposition had to be put off. OAG lawyers used this speed bump to immediately filed a motion in U.S. District Court to bar Hustler from giving his deposition.

The detective was at Pershing Park during the mass arrest incident. It is unclear what he would have said under oath.

Whatever Hustler was going to say, OAG lawyers argued, it was going to be old news. Therefore, he shouldn't be deposed.

But then they write this: "Federal courts have broad authority to limit discovery as necessary to 'protect a party or person from annoyance, embarrassment, oppression, or undue burden or expense.'"

Plaintiffs lawyers have filed their own response with the court:

"The District's current motion is a particularly striking example of how openly baseless the District's recent actions have become. The District seeks to stymie Plaintiffs' good-faith discovery efforts on the grounds that the District is unsure whether the deposition is based on the production of late evidence despite the fact that the District was told by both Barham and Chang counsel that he will be questioned on such evidence. It is noteworthy that the District did not raise a similar objection when Detective Hustler was properly noticed by the Barham plaintiffs on November 4, 20009."

They go on to write: "In fact, if the District's sudden alarm is any indication, Detective Hustler appears to be a key witness to the protests and arrests on September 27, 2002."

One other interesting note:  Mark Tuohey, former D.C. Police Chief Charles H. Ramsey's lawyer, had shown up popped up graced everyone with his attendance attended Hustler's deposition as well.

Blog Widget by LinkWithin
  • Comrade Al Gonzales

    Nice name. Hustler. Mr. Hustler. Det. Hustler. Hustler, Paul Hustler. Pleased to meet you. Punk.

  • jf1

    "shown up"?

    what is that supposed to mean, instead of "appeared"

  • downtown rez

    "Shown up" is at least better than "popped up graced", both of which are added redundantly as though a 1st draft editing mistake.

  • Jason Cherkis

    Downtown Rez: I was just trying to be funny. I fail.

  • proballdc

    Peter Nickles is a disgrace to the District. We have an attorney general who casually obstructs justice. Without apology. He is a primary reason folks don't like his boss.

  • EdTheRed

    To quote the Jesus: "This bush league psyche-out stuff. Laughable, man - ha!"