City Desk

Isn’t New York Supposed to Have All the Stars?

Those of you who couldn’t wait for the New York Times to hit the publish button last night—and you know who you are—have already dissected this piece like a lab specimen. But for you non-obsessives, here’s critic Frank Bruni’s review of Fiamma, the sort-of Italian, sort-of not restaurant that lured away former Maestro toque (and Beard Award winner) Fabio Trabocchi.

Before Trabocchi split for the Big Apple, he earned four stars from both the Washington Post and the Washingtonian. In Bruni’s estimation, the chef rates no better than three. Is this a case of D.C. critics being too easy or the Times being too hard? Or perhaps New Yorkers just can’t hand out four stars to newcomers, particularly those from the District. Discuss.

4 Responses to “Isn’t New York Supposed to Have All the Stars?”

  1. Lou Says:

    Well, you gotta admit the competition in NYC is just a tad higher than here in the mighty DoC.

  2. Bob Says:

    No matter how many stars, it seemed pretty much a rave review to me.

  3. Paul Says:

    Having been to both Maestro and Fiamma since Fabio started, I think the respective 4 and 3 star ratings were accurate at the time. However, considering that the 4 star DC rating was after Maestro had been in operation for a couple of years, and that Fabio has only been at Fiamma for a couple of months, I have no doubt that Fiamma will soon merit a 4 star ranking. In the last 3 months, Fiamma has gotten into its groove and is now better than ever.

    At this point, I would rank Fiamma on par with other top NYC restaurants, such as Bouley or Daniel.

  4. Heather Says:

    Washington critics are too easy. I have lost count of the number of restaurants that get raves here, and yet manage to disappoint me time after time.

Leave a Reply

Inauguration Housing and Inauguratin Rentals
Shop Local
DC SEARCH
calendar
restaurants
movies
classified
personals

Find an Event

Select the type of event, and the particular day this week below.

Submit your event to the City Paper's Event Calendar.

Find a Restaurant

Enter a restaurant name, or select a cuisine and neighborhood below.

Find a Movie

Select a movie theater in the box below to see a list of all movies at that theater.

...Or view a full list of theaters, films, and showtimes.

Search Classified Ads

Post a Classified Ad

Find It

Find a Match

Age range: to
Find It

Who saw you? Check I Saw You
Looking for something kinky? Wild Side

City Paper Newsletter
advertisement
CarTango

Get a Car

Search inventory on the City Paper's CarTango website:

CP Events

Can I have seconds?

This Week

Current Issue
The Issue of Nov. 27 - Dec. 3, 2008

This Week in
City Paper History

  • Exit Strategy
    Is Anthony Falzarano's effort to help gays go straight sexual healing or a way to deny reality?
    Nov. 26 - Dec. 2, 1999
  • Midget Wrestling
    Wannabe politicos come to D.C. colleges to soak up the federal ambiance. In the age of Starr and Lewinsky, they're learning their lessons well.
    Nov. 26 - Dec. 2, 1999
  • Soulsby on Ice
    MPD Chief Larry Soulsby has finally run out of denials.
    Nov. 28 - Dec. 4, 1997
advertisement
advertisement