Politics and Prose's Social Network How much is a beloved bookstore really worth?

Page 4 of 5

The secret sauce is its mix of functions for big shots and lesser-known writers. For instance, this past month, National Book Award-winning biographer Ron Chernow and former Secretary of State Condoleezza Rice spoke at the store, as did novelists Myla Goldberg and Dinaw Mengestu. Plus, the store hosts 17 book groups on topics ranging from James Joyce to graphic novels. Each group meeting usually brings in two dozen readers, Meade says, who often peruse the shelves before and after.

It looked like I stumbled upon the most popular ornithological seminar ever. Clusters of college students and office workers were milling about at 6 p.m. Friday on the steps of George Washington University’s Lisner Auditorium, each carrying a tome with a blue bird on the cover. They had come early to grab a seat to hear Jonathan Franzen speak about his new book, Freedom. The talk was originally scheduled for Politics and Prose, but the staff changed the venue because of the expected crowds. More than 900 people turned out.

For authors, a nod from a place like P&P is a big deal. Writers who can’t gain an Oprah endorsement or Time magazine cover, like Franzen, have to rely on independent bookstores to generate interest. Novelist Wallace Stegner said Carla Cohen lifted his work to the national stage. Lucy Kogler, manager of Talking Leaves Books in Buffalo, N.Y., says she was a champion of first-time Abraham Verghese’s Cutting for Stone, well before the book captured critical acclaim.

But hosting and championing writers also pays off for stores. P&P’s ability to host the Franzen event—and sell 700 books as a result—represents a chunk of sales that your average shopping-mall bookstore, or Internet giant, doesn’t get. “Amazon and the Kindle don’t build community,” says Andy Shallal, owner of Busboys and Poets, the local chain of restaurants/bookstores.

It’s no wonder, then, that newer stores have sought to take P&P’s bread and butter—literature as spectacle—and render it even more spectacular, if not quite as literary. Shallal’s establishment near 14th and U streets NW, on a strip that is as hopping as upper Connecticut Avenue is sleepy, has a full-on restaurant, rather than a mere coffee shop. It hosts concerts and performances that draw a younger crowd than the generally gray-haired regulars at Politics and Prose. Busboys & Poets has a staff of five planners who schedule events at eight different spaces in three locations: the original 14th Street NW space, 5th and K streets NW, and one in Arlington’s Shirlington neighborhood. (Having been initially inspired by evocations of the African-American literary renaissance of the 1920s, Shallal is now planning a New York outpost in Harlem.) Unlike Politics and Prose, Busboys & Poets charges for many of its events, $4 a head on open-mic poetry night or, recently, $50 per person for a dance party celebrating a new book from Alice Walker and $70 per person if you wanted a signed copy. Bookselling is a smaller part of this mix. The bookstores in Shallal’s establishments are run by a non-profit, Teaching for Change. The book part of the business has been constant, but not growing, he says. Where Cohen used to speak reverentially about reading, Shallal thinks most of his customers don’t actually read what they buy. “They put them on a shelf. They just want a reminder of the experience,” he says.


All the same, Busboys and Poets may represent a vision of bookselling’s future. Since he opened his third Busboys and Poets in a Mount Vernon Triangle condo project in 2008, Shallal says he received about 20 offers from developers to operate at various other locations. Busboys & Poets has 800 square feet of bookselling space, which is less than one-tenth of Politics and Prose’s space, and offers some progressive titles you may not find at Politics and Prose. But it’s telling that Shallal talks about dining, an activity you can’t do electronically, when he celebrates the community that he’s brought together. “In Washington, you rarely see blacks and whites eating together,” he says. “Busboys & Poets has that.”

I went to the 14th Street NW Busboys and Poets on a Friday night in October for dinner. My table wedged between a white hipster couple and a group of four young African-American women in the back of the restaurant. The scene was diverse and vibrant, especially compared with the older, whiter crowd at Politics and Prose. But from the restaurant, you couldn’t tell Busboys & Poets had a bookstore. After dinner, I squeezed into the stacks to avoid the line of people waiting for a table. There were no handy staff recommendations posted under the books, like Politics and Prose has, and no quiet place to browse before buying. The book section felt like a kiosk.

Our Readers Say

wow. lovely depiction of p&p but some of the comments/errors made regarding teaching for change's bookstore at busboy's in poets are really unfortunate. the teaching for change bookstore (which is only located inside of the BB&P restaurant at 14th and v sts, nw) actually hosts several FREE author events a week. the open mic referred to in the article is hosted by the restaurant, not the bookstore (they are actually two cooperative but separate entities). and the dance party for alice walker's book was held at the 5th and K sts busboys with which the teaching for change bookstore is not affiliated.

i'm a washingtonian and appreciate p&p's presence. but the bookstore at 14th and V bb&p is particularly special to me because of its commitment to and focus on promoting progressive titles and author events. and i read ALL of the books i purchase there (at least, all the ones i don't give as gifts).
Great article... but why the Busboys and Poets misrepresentations? The vast majority of events are free at BB&P and the atmosphere at the bookstore really brings together diverse people into one vibrant place. It, too, is a DC institution and I believe the successes of Busboys and Politics/Prose are COMPLIMENTARY. They, simply, both echo the same message; making books and exchanging thoughtful ideas 'cool' in Washington.
While I think P&P is great, Teaching for Change’s Busboys and Poets Bookstore is an incredible place. I was first introduced to Teaching for Change and Busboys and Poets by my graduate college professor at Trinity College where I was working toward a degree in Curriculum and Instruction with a focus in Reading. Once I experienced the large selection of multicultural titles, I was hooked. The Teaching for Change Bookstore at Busboys and Poets is a great source for children’s literature that speaks to a variety of audiences from early emergent readers to adults. The high-quality literature selection encourages children and adults to actively engage in a wide variety of genre and create meaningful connections to themes, characters, and ideas. I appreciate the collection of rich and authentic literature as well as the free author events.
Like many in the Washington literary community, I mourn Carla Cohen's passing, and before that, worried about the news that Politics & Prose was on the block. I'm glad for the hopeful information in this article that promises a strong future for this amazing independent bookstore--a stellar model of success in an industry where success is lately hard to find. But I'm disturbed by the many errors here about another superlative literary venue in our city, Busboys & Poets Bookstore, operated by Teaching for Change. Nowhere in Washington can you find such a dedicated collection of great (and diverse) world literature and important and timely books on government, social justice, education and international issues.

For me it's as equal a destination for good reading for all ages as Politics & Prose, and its events (free) and authors have as much cachet as the uptown institution. Because the shelf space is indeed limited, the helpful staff is more than willing to order any book for you, though the selection is so thoughtful I often will find a vital book I didn't even know I needed. The event space is exceptional, and the open mic nights (also free) are an important community and arts effort that platforms many writers and poets whose work doesn't have big publisher backing. I cherish both establishments, and wish this article had described the smaller store more fairly. Thank you.
Politics and Prose is a wonderful bookstore no doubt, but to argue that the Teaching for Change bookstore in Busboys and Poets on 14th and V is like a kiosk is outrageous. Not only does Busboys have the best poetry collection anywhere in the city, it has become the place to get books on politics, on progressive movements, on diversity. One of the failures to adopt to a digital culture is to feel that to praise one entity requires the diminishing of another. The two stores serve both represent the eclectic and ambitious possibilities of the city. Unfortunately, they also represent the real threat of places like this only appealing to a certain class of people. One thing I admire about Busboys is the consistent ability to pack the house, for often unheard poets, at the Nine on the Ninth Events. This reading series, run by their Poet-in-Residence, Derrick Weston Brown is free - and brings a wildly diverse mix of people in one room once a month to listen to poetry. I’ve benefitted from reading there - and know any poet who has would never complain about audience.

I have been saddened by the disappearance of independent bookstores in our city and hope that new ownership will not dilute P & P's presence in DC. It is unfortunate that the article pitted two great bookstores against each other rather than celebrate what each has to offer our community. Living in a diverse city, I know that I can easily find children's books at Busboys and Poets that reflect and honor the diversity of my children and their friends. The staff at Busboys and Poets are incredibly helpful and willing to find books that I learn about through Teaching Tolerance and other progressive magazines and websites. I work with a lot of people who visit DC and I always encourage them to go to Busboys and Poets for dinner, events and, most importantly, the bookstore. Being surrounded by progressive books that offer insight into the challenging issues of our time and realizing that there are creative resources to help us begin conversations with our children about creating change is a rare and inspiring experience that everyone needs to have!
Busboys and Poets has a great bookstore operated by an NGO and gives back to the community more than any other restaurant in washington, dc. All their author events are free. Let's get our facts right next time, City Paper. Busboys and Poets is a great concept and jealousy shouldn't be a motivation for a story.
Count me as another person who doesn't see why the writer here needs to slam one independent bookstore in order to praise another. I absolutely treasure the bookstore at Busboys. The workers at Busboys are incredibly knowledgeable about a dizzying array of books. I remember telling the store manager Don Allen that I was into detective noir and his response, "Have you ever read one set in Laos?" speaks for itself. At both Busboys and P&P, there is a strong sense of community, conversation, and titles well-beyond the norm. The fact that Busboys is run by Teaching for Change, only adds to its sense of mission and makes it a truly special place. Of course Busboys is 1/10 the size of P and P. But a brilliant restaurant with just four tables is a detail, not a determining feature. Busboys is a brilliant bookstore and if you don't believe me, see for yourself.
As an alternative high school teacher, the Teaching for Change Bookstore at Busboys and Poets is one of the few places I can find great books (both for myself and my students) and feel good about supporting a local, independent bookstore and excellent organization. When I have books I need to order for gifts or for my classroom, I simply e-mail Don at the bookstore and he places the orders for me, so I rarely set foot in big box bookstores. Also, I have met several excellent authors at the free author events at Busboys and Poets hosted by Teaching for Change.
Some people seem a little touchy. I didn't take the piece as a slam of Busboys and Poets...just that they were different. Also, if their book section "felt like a kiosk" to the writer, then it felt like a kiosk, you know?
Good point, Scott. The responses answer the article's subtitle, though: How much is a beloved bookstore really worth?

A lot.

It is unfortunate that in this day and time we are still subjected to pitting one against the other. Promoting competition between two of the most successful progressive venues in the city is deplorable and does not serve our community’s best interest. This would have been a great article by merely telling Politics & Prose great story, mourning their lost and discussing their future. The criticisms of Busboys & Poets were unfounded and unnecessary. As for instance, if I were to criticize Politics & Prose for hosting Condoleezza Rice's book event and charge that Howard Zinn must be turning over in his grave would be unfair. I patronize both establishments and met Alice Walker and Howard Zinn initially at Politics & Prose then enjoyed them both up close and personal at Busboys and Poets. Does that make me old and cool? Both of these establishments are products of their locations as is the inflammatory insight in this article the product of the narrow focus of this author's life experiences.
Both Busboys and Poets and Politics and Prose are unique, independent gems of DC. They have different vibes but both merit respect for what they provide: an intellectually stimulating environment in which race, politics and culture are created and debated. Most of the B&P and P&P events I attend attract a knowledgeable crowd who enjoy an interesting conversation about what they read. While a few events at B&P might require a cover, the vast majority is free and provide access to beer or a glass of wine. In the debate over the pros and cons between B&P and P&P, let’s not forget the other independent bookstores around the city, such as Reiter’s, Kramerbooks, and SisterSpace, for they are fighting the same technological advances that are phasing out the indies like Olsson’s. Let’s support all of our precious independent bookstores.
Through the 18 years I've worked to train new bookstore owners and advise independent booksellers, I must correct your use of 'gross margin' and calculation of a 15% profit margin. Not! There are many successful bookstore institutions like P&P who do so many things right, but keep in mind that about $6 of every $10 book goes back to the publisher, then another $2 goes to staff, $1 for rent, and there isn't possibly 15% after everybody else gets paid.
Most booksellers are in the business because they respect and are enriched by books and reading, enjoy creating a sense of community, and love using their skills in the book industry.
There are communities who have lost ... and will lose ... their chain stores and this leaves a tremendous opportunity for entrepreneurs around the country who want to establish a community bookstore. Ebooks are another way to read books and indie booksellers will have a way to sell Google editions (device agnostic!) and still get a piece of this business as it continues to grow and will eventually level off.
If you enjoy browsing for books and appreciate the curated selection of your independent bookstore, don't go home and buy from Amazon. Recognize the value of having local businesses on your Main Street and the presence caring members of your business community who support the arts as well as Little League. A sustainable indie bookstore in a town not only the result of savvy business owners, it is also the mark of citizens who value its presence and wish to patronize local businesses to ensure the community's vitality.

Leave a Comment

Note: HTML tags are not allowed in comments.
Comments Shown. Turn Comments Off.