The District Line

Missing the Bus Metro’s fare hike squeezes commuters. But what about the children?

Pass Imperfect: With Metro costs going up, Jenkins can’t always afford to get to class.
Darrow Montgomery

For 17-year-old Roneka Jenkins and her siblings, the beginning of the month often brings a tough choice: food or school.

Jenkins is one of 10 children, seven of whom are school-age. She attends Thurgood Marshall Academy Public Charter High School in Southeast and scored a college scholarship for up to $50,000 last year from the District of Columbia College Success Foundation.

For years, Jenkins and her family have used Metro’s SmartStudent monthly passes to get around. She takes the V7, V8, or V9 bus from home. Then, she gets off at Pennsylvania Avenue SE and transfers to the B2. Her siblings take a mix of buses and trains. Since Jenkins started high school, there have been at least a dozen times, she estimates, that some of her siblings have had to miss school at the beginning of the month because the family simply couldn’t afford all the passes. Around that period, the budget always tightens.

“We try to save money from the past month. We don’t go grocery shopping until later that month,” she says. “We eat breakfast and lunch at school, macaroni or cereal for dinner.”

And that happened before the price hike.

As of January 2008, the cost of the pass jumped from $22 to $26, part of a massive package of fare increases approved by Metro in December.

This month, some of Jenkins’ siblings didn’t get the pass until Feb. 12. In the interim, they were mostly “staying at home or being out in the streets,” Jenkins says. “I worry about them getting in trouble.”

Plenty of other kids are feeling the pinch as well. Students attending schools across the city say they’re struggling to keep up with the price hike. Parents expect to give their kids a certain amount of money for the pass. Between groceries and bills, they haven’t adjusted to the change.

Jenkins’ mother, Rosalyn Harling, says she starts saving money for the passes in the middle of each month. She believes she’s not the only parent worried about absorbing the cost adjustment. “I have heard a couple parents say things when they went to buy passes. And I know for a fact it’s been a struggle for me. That’s like a whole other bill,” says Harling, who works as a bus attendant for the D.C. public schools.

When it comes to finding four extra dollars, the kids often have to make up the difference. “Some people just don’t have money to spend like that. They have to squeeze their pennies,” says Kris Stith, a junior at Duke Ellington School of the Arts in Georgetown. When some students think about fare changes, he says, they anticipate paying a few more cents for the bus or train. But paying four more dollars all at once?

“Does it cost that much extra to print plastic?” Stith jokes. The day he planned to buy the pass for this month, he forgot about the price change and brought the wrong amount of money to school. Then he had to cobble together funds for the next school day and find the money for the pass.

Already, many of Stith’s schoolmates work at shops in Georgetown. Stith and his twin brother Keagoe both get stipends from a tutoring program in Southeast. For them, the price hike has mostly been a hassle.

Metro announced its proposed fare hike last fall. In November, there were two public hearings in the District to solicit comments. DCPS, however, was not fully informed of how the changes might affect its student body, says schools spokesperson Mafara Hobson.

“Everybody I asked, no one even knew the increase was coming. I can say there was no outreach,” says Hobson. “I even spoke to the deputy mayor [Victor Reinoso], and he didn’t know anything about it.”

Tyesha Sands, a senior at Young America Works Public Charter Vocational High School in Northeast, says she missed five days earlier this month, since she wasn’t able to gather enough money right away. “It really throws my whole schedule out of whack,” she says. “It’s frustrating. It’s boring, too. I don’t like to miss school.”

Some students have used the new price to justify skipping school, Sands says. Pre-hike, the cost was already steep, she explains. Now, people complain that $26 is just too high.

“A lot of my friends that used to come to school a lot just stopped coming,” says Sands. “Some students are looking for a reason not to come.”

Peter N. Smith, principal of the Young America Works school, says he hasn’t noticed a drop in attendance since Metro prices increased. But even before the change went into effect, he and other staff members frequently provided students with money to buy their passes.

“We’ve done it in the past, but I know I’ve done it in the past two months, too. We just do it out of our own pocket,” he says. “I know that for kids coming from east of the Anacostia River, that’s been a huge challenge. A lot of parents just don’t have it.”

Smith says he’s considering doling out free Metro passes to honor roll students as an incentive to work hard.

At Jenkins’ house, a careful selection process governs which siblings get to go to school and which siblings don’t. Since she is a graduating, college-bound senior, she often gets preference. This month, she and her 13-year-old sister Shamika both got passes on the first day of the month. The next day, her aunt bought a pass for her 14-year-old sister, Jasmine. The following week, one of her sisters stayed out of school so her brother could take the bus to study for his G.E.D. test.

If all goes according to plan, Jenkins will graduate and then head off to University of Maryland-Eastern Shore. She purposely chose that school because it was close. Out of all her siblings, she’s the only one with a job; she works with Stith at the nonprofit in Southeast. Her mom relies on her to help with groceries and other expenses.

As for the upcoming months, Jenkins expects the Metro trade-offs to diminish. She says she’s going to get some days off for senior class trips and portfolio week, a time when seniors do special independent projects and don’t come to school every day.

“Then, we can just split passes,” she says.

Our Readers Say

The real question is: Why the hell do you have 10 children that you obviously cannot afford??

Children don't ask to come here and they certainly shouldn't have to choose between food and getting to school.
Why don't children ride FREE on school days? They do in other cities.
No question - this is not abut the difference between $154 and $176 - each school, charter or public, can purchase farecards for students in need. Teachers often go into their pockets, but this is not necessary. One area that charter schools are making out like bandits is not utilizing a bus service for their students.

Families shoulc not have to shell out private transportation dollars to organizations that exist not on a shoestring, but a well planned budget that is nearly completely subsidized with public funds.

This is a city council / school issue, that has trickled down to be solved by the vulnerable and easily pushed over. They've been told this is the way it is.
"Jenkins is one of 10 children, seven of whom are school-age. ...At Jenkins’ house, a careful selection process governs which siblings get to go to school and which siblings don’t."

Jebus, what a hot ghetto mess. Poor girl...
If DC Council can PARK FREE why can't STUDENTS ride METRO FREE?
Transpotation is essential for public school students. Families should not have to choose between providing transportation for school and groceries. I strongly encourage the Transportation system to work in partnership with the schools to create a system that is not a burden for families.
"If DC Council can PARK FREE why can't STUDENTS ride METRO FREE?"

'They can kill the Kennedys. Why can't they make a cup of coffee that tastes good?'
Well, I do not have any children but I do what I can and volunteer with teaching ESL to Haitian refugees here in DC. I would love to know if there is some fund that we could donate a little of our money to help these kids out. $4 a month is not a lot of money to me, but it makes a huge difference in someone else's life... Is there something that we can do?
This article did a poor job of providing background to those of us not familiar with DC Public Schools -- why are students paying for transportation to school in the first place?

I grew up in the country, in southwestern Pennsylvania, and a school bus picked me up at my house each day. "I couldn't get here" would have never been an acceptable excuse for a failure to attend.

In a city with an extensive transit network, and a society which (supposedly) values public education, why are these students not provided with transportation to school? Alternately, why are they not provided with schools within walking distance of their homes?
Grumpy's right. My taxes go to educate other people's kids. They can't even get them to school? Where I went to school, there were NO BUSES, and parents brought their kids to school, or THEY WALKED... sometimes miles.
How many of these poverty-stricken, "starving" children are CLINICALLY OBESE?
You should study that and get back to us. I already know the answer, having worked "in the community." The food they were going without was the third bag of doritoes. As you stated clearly in the article, some kids are just looking for an excuse not to go to school. Go ahead, blame the city and the cost to ride the murderous Metrobuses. I blame the society that supports their lack of respect and lack of desire for education, no matter how hard it may be to attain.
OK .. I UNDERSTAND THAT SOME PEOPLE JOKE THA THEY DON'T HAVE THAT MANY CHILDREN. MY ADVISE TO THEM IS TO PUT THEIR SELF IN OTHERS SHOES.. TRY NOT TO BE A SNOB. THESE ARE SERIOUS ISSUES IN DC TODAY.
DC is really small, much less than 5 mile in most places, and its very widest 13 mi across (see link below). So can it really be that kids can't walk less than an hour to school (1 mi = 15 min)!? I am not saying this is ideal, transportation is, - but it is by no means impossible or extraordinary, in fact. There are also many other combinations, for example, alternate your route, take the bus (~$1.50) in some places and walk in others and so on.

Unfortunately, the problem is not really one of access, but one of motivation, much harder to fix.

Finally, dare I bring these up: "We walked 10 mi in the snow, uphill, both ways..."
"There are kids all over the world who would kill to be able to walk to school within 10 mi...."
Etc.


http://maps.google.com/maps?f=d&hl=en&geocode=15622016423648365082,38.936640,-77.108700&saddr=Unknown+road+%4038.936640,+-77.108700&daddr=38.892703,-76.916399&mra=mi&mrsp=1,0&sz=14&sll=38.892636,-76.916142&sspn=0.048633,0.079823&ie=UTF8&ll=38.97329,-76.956482&spn=0.388624,0.63858&z=11
Food or ride to school? I find that hard to believe. It’s a fact that poor people have a short time horizon and blow all of their cash on "ICE" , "22's" , and other "G'd up" stuff. Maybe these parents need a finance course. I would gladly teach it to them.

Lesson 1: you are not P diddy so stop making it rain
Lesson 2: those fake nails and that bad weave aren’t fooling anyone. Grow UP!


Is it that big of a deal that those kids without an academic future miss school? We are not all equal. Some do math others bag groceries. Those that want to go to school will get there those that don’t wont…and bag my groceries or rob me in a couple of years. In case you forgot, division of labor is key to U.S. productivity.

Let’s be honest with these kids and tell them the truth. Since no one is saying it I will.

To ALL DC PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENTS:
You are poor, have no future, and lack a strong work ethic. Stop wasting my tax dollars on a skill which you have no intention to master or apply. Instead, learn to dribble a ball, hit the high notes at the church choir, or dance reaaaal good.


God Bless,
LBH
Why you all hatting on us kids. I aint tryting to walk no 5 miles to get to classs. I wanna look good when I get there ans spit game to the shortys worldwide. so help me get on the bus. My people aint fight through all them cival war years for nutting. Know what I mean jelly bean?

I look out for the city shouyldnt the city look out for me.

AIGHT!!!
ASS
DC Sucks I am moving back to Baltimore
Grumpy, C & Lets Be Honest: please save your whining for the KKK meetings. Much love to DC youth who struggle out there to make it every day. Keep ya head up!!
I remeber the days I had to buy my smart students passes. I think it's sad that DCPS students have to rely on metro to get to school, especially when metro is faling apart. For those ignorant people who made comments above, please understand that though you may have walked to school back when; DC is a mini war zone. It isn't safe to walk to school, and some children go to school further away from their homes. I think it is sad that metro continues to raise fares, yet their service is horrible. DC Government should really rethink their transportation methods.
Grumpy, C & Let's Be Honest:

I pray you never run out of change and find yourself having to take the bus somewhere in DC......by yourself....at night or run out of gas and find yourself in bad part of town. You just may run across one of these kids who doesn't have anything better to do than to beat the hell out of you just for fun!!

There's nothing more dangerous than a person with no hope and nothing to lose. Let's at least give them a chance. If they want to go to school, they should be able to go.
Grumpy, C, & Let's Be Honest,

I pray you never run out of change and have to take the bus in DC or run out of gas at night, when you're by yourself, in a bad neighborhood. You might just run across one of these kids who has nothing better to do than to beat the hell out of you simply because they didn't have a chance.

There's nothing more dangerous than a person with no hope and nothing to lose. If they want to go to school, they should at least be able to go.
Would you want your children to walk BY THEMSELVES through the city of DC? Especially crossing busy roads and in sketchy neighborhoods??

Sure, I probably would have been fine walking to school by myself in the beautifully manicured suburb I grew up in, but no, I got a free bus ride to go to the public school less than a mile away.

And I ate Doritos in the suburbs too.
Fight the power: which is it? will they jump me for fun? or cuz they didn't have a chance? seems they're interchangeable in your mind. In theirs, too probably. Either way - next time I don't have change for the bus and have to walk through a bad hood - like once last month when I walked 2 hours to get home, (but luckily nobody noticed my big white hood (la mas xingona), so I wasn't jumped) - When I get jumped, raped, and killed, I'll be just another statistic stain on the street, and your retarded kids will still be criminals with no hope because you raised them to believe that they have to rely on the government or ANYONE other than themselves to get along in life. So they'll have their babies and their free government cheese, and live off welfare, and blame my long dead ass for all their problems, and teach their babies the same screwed up crap you preach here. It's my fault, my dead corpse in the road who wouldn't vote to give you more of my money that I worked for. Bite me.
Comment by Walk Feb. 26, 2008, at 2:46 pm
DC is really small, much less than 5 mile in most places, and its very widest 13 mi across (see link below). So can it really be that kids can't walk less than an hour to school (1 mi = 15 min)!? I am not saying this is ideal, transportation is, - but it is by no means impossible or extraordinary, in fact. There are also many other combinations, for example, alternate your route, take the bus (~$1.50) in some places and walk in others and so on.

When you get the chance, walk from 16th and Good Hope Rd SE to Hardy Middle School in Georgetown. Now imagine a middle schooler doing that. My child wouldn't have to catch the bus to Hardy had the schools in our SE neighborhood been any good. Her teacher recommended for her to attend that school.
Comment by Fight The Power Feb. 29, 2008, at 9:19 am
Grumpy, C, & Let's Be Honest,

I pray you never run out of change and have to take the bus in DC or run out of gas at night, when you're by yourself, in a bad neighborhood. You might just run across one of these kids who has nothing better to do than to beat the hell out of you simply because they didn't have a chance.

-------------------------------------------------------------------------
Fight the Power's prayers did not work for me - last fall i was in such a situation and was robbed at gunpoint by two young ...fill in the rest with what unfortunately comes to mind. Honestly, the fact that it was the stereotype, down to the type of clothes, sickened me more than the fact of being robbed.

And I am conflicted now. For the first time in my life, i get an automatic panicky rising in my gut when i'm alone and I see a black man on the street - are you sure that wouldn't happen to you? Would you now ignore your own survivial instinct that resulted from a factual situation? Its tough but what i'm trying to do is balance paying attention to my intuition while also continually reminding myself that everyone is a different individual.

So it all goes back to motivation... As i said in my previous post, walking is not ideal, transportation is, but that distracts from the main issue: How much are kids motivated to go to school and how much to rob people. Everyone's motivated in something, the CEO in profits, the user in getting the next hit and chillin, and the average American in continuing their daily lives blissfully ignorant. Gotta figure out the motivation.

I think that this is a deeply complex issue, probably the most in America today and that a good amount of "walk a mile in my shoes" understanding is missing. I know that as an immigrant, it deeply offends me when "regular" Americans think they know what my mom and I have gone through as if they've lived it. But that attempt at understanding seems to too often morph into a provision of excuses. A prime example here is, "metro fare went up, can't go to school now," as mentioned in the main article.

Finally, one thing that i am sure of is that political correctness is doing much more harm than any good to the African-American community, in DC and nationwide, because it prevents anyone and everyone from taking the crucial universal step to solving problems - that is, acknowledging them.
Wow...what ridiculous, racist, and evil, people read the CityPaper these days. But I guess since they have the same First Amendment Rights to spout their views, so do I.

First off, to Grumpy, C & Lets Be Honest, and whoever else wants to read this, the real issue behind the story is one of economics. Sure, you can talk about Bay-Bay and her 9 kids, but clearly DC isn't the only urban demographic with that issue. DCPS is the only school system I know of that does not have busing. I could discuss that and the ramifications from the 50's, 60's, and 70's, but I'll save that for another blog. Please understand that the shape the DC children are in is not solely because of themselves or any family dynamic. There are also external forces at play. In this case, one of those forces is the declining economy and the jobless rate.

I am a College Educated, close to six-figure salaried, product of the DCPS. If even I can see the impact of $4 on the likes on potentially 50,000 children (DCPS' current enrollment), surely the bloggers whom venom so easily spews from can see that as well. When I was in school, I walked from 1 block (elementary), to 8 blocks (junior high), to as much as 13 blocks (high school) to school. Granted, there was some opportunity to ride metro, but neighborhood schools were better then and my parents valued public education.

Fast forward some 20 years later...schools are not in the same shape they were in even 10 years ago. The landscape and almost state-sponsored gentrification is rampant. Not that kids need or have an excuse to miss school, but in this day in age, we want to give children ALL OPPORTUNITY TO EXCEL. True, they gotta want it, but at the same time we surely shouldn't be inhibiting them. I didn't have 9 other siblings, but I had friends who had plenty. Even $1 extrapolated across a 3 child household can be detrimental.

Stop complaining and condemning DCPS kids and start supporting them. And I mean in addition to your tax dollars that pay the welfare recipients. You folks that are out there condemning them don't realize that the generation of these children are going to be the ones whose income will be paying for your Social Security. You don't realize that these children will be working in the McDonalds, etc. you frequent, etc. Yes some of the attitudes of the children are messed up, even from when I was in school. But that still does not relenquish your responsibility in helping to shape public policy and giving back to make this city better.

You didn't make it all by yourself. There were extra-family infrastructures in place that afforded you the comfort where now you can even make ridiculous comments like you are doing.

I'm like the other blogger. Tell me where I can give at least $4 a month (if not $40) to subsidize a school pass and I'll do it. I won't wait for DCPS, or City Council, or even Metro to get their collective acts together. I want to help the children of DCPS NOW! I suggest anyone who reads this do the same.
Damn, yo, don't come to Baltimore to get away. Here the little animals are given discounted fares on the buses and we have Middle Schoolers attacking people on the bus. It's a city sport for the poor wittle disenfranchised to attack decent people on our public transportation system. Before I moved, I walked 2.5 miles to work and 2.5 miles back rather than get on the bus because of the way the animal school "children" acted.

I pay enough in taxes, you want to have 10 little bastards you can't pay for? Tough. Not my problem. Learn to control yourself.
Reality Bites - you are so wise. Please run for office.
Before you get an animal from the pound, you have to prove you can provide a good living situation for that animal. Unfortunately no such rule applies to parenting. When you have a child, you are responsible for ALL of the expenses incurred in raising that child to include clothing, food, education, and healthcare, just like I have to pay for vet bills and toys for my animal. I AM NOT RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR BAD DECISIONS, AND YOU CAN'T MAKE ME BECOME RESPONSIBLE FOR YOUR CHILDREN AND THEIR EXPENSES. Pay your own bills.
My taxes should pay for things we all use commonly - like our pothole-ridden roads and emergency services that come within the same season of an initial call to 911... park rangers... museums... street sweepers... corrupt tax collectors... If you want an education system that's equal from LA to DC, then you have to release the funding from the property tax base, and make the system federally funded, like it is in - dare I say it? - France. But they're socialists. We're not. Or at least I'm not - and as far as I know neither is my government.
Isn't it ironic that right next to the United States capital we have children living in strife. I find it embarrassing that our officials can take care of people from the other side of the planet, yet right down the street there are children who have to make a choice between feeding their minds or their stomachs.

As far as the ignorance that I have read from "tax paying" citizens. Your assumptions that tax dollars are going to the poor are very misguided. You better take closer look at your congressman. In fact funds for social welfare are being cut at alarming rates. So Jeb and Rufus, I doubt that your $10 in taxes is going to anything else but guns to fight a pointless war.
JR...Why don’t you just grow a pair!

Q...I admire your energy in presenting your case but it’s inherently flawed. You assume that by giving kids a ride to school we will improve our city. I think you are young and don’t have enough world experience to understand that poor people stay poor rich people stay rich- regardless of what social programs are offered (Try reading a book). While you may be making it rain with your “close to six figures" You are the exception.

You are right when you say I had a lot of support when I was growing up. And it is that support that largely made me in to the very rich person I am today. In case you are wondering...It was my parents and only my parents (both immigrants from Cuba) maybe the parents of these children should stop expecting handouts and just do their job.
l I am a native Washingtonian and third generation DC PUBLIC school alumni. I have a great job, my parents were never "poor" I grew up in a middle class African American neighborhood in DC. Some of these post's are insanely racist but I'm not surprised. As for former and current DCPS students who grew up poor, many of those students have graduated from DCPS and in doing so ended the cycle of poverty plaguing some of their families.

The REAL problem with the DCPS system has nothing to do with transportation and everything to do with the mis-management of public school funding, deterioration of school buildings, unqualified teachers etc. We have a gigantic brand spankin new baseball stadium yet DCPS are falling apart. Politics are usual. On another note:


LISTEN UP ALL DC PUBLIC SCHOOL STUDENTS:


LET YOUR HATER'S BE YOUR MOTIVATORS. You will always have hater's, especially the ones that lack melanin. I repeat LET YOUR HATER'S BE YOUR MOTIVATORS. I know that right now you are facing immeasurable odds but hang in there. Let the generations of African American DCPS students that have come before you be your shining examples of excellence! We too faced many obstacles in school, at times in our homes and in society.

However, in spite of those challenges, we studied hard, fought the good fight and in doing so received a lot of KNOWLEDGE in the process, which is priceless! Stay encouraged my young brothers and sisters. Also, the last time I checked DC was still a AFRICAN AMERICAN majority so who exactly is LB referring to when he says " stop wasting our tax dollars"??? Ignore racist stupidity and continue on the road to success with your heads held high!


Aisha

Eastern Sr. High School Alumni
Class of '1997
Age: 28
Current Position: Contract Specialist
Current Income: 75k Per/ yr
LBH the "analysis" below is BULL'ISH. What group of poor people are you referring too??

Poor white trash?

Poor Black people aren't walking around "G'd" up. What exactly does G'd up mean anyway? I guess that's a word corny whiteboys use when trying to imitate cool Black slang. Rappers and entertainers are the ones with money to burn so they are the one's wearing bling and driving cars that you won't be able to afford in your lifetime, not poor black people. Poor black people know how to make a dollar out of 15 cents. Stop taking about a subject you know nothing about. Your stupidity is mind boggling. Why don't you teach a class to suburban kids about depression not being an excuse to shoot teachers and classmates.


Aisha

_________________________________________________________________
" It is a fact that poor people have a short time horizon and blow all of their cash on "ICE" , "22's" , and other "G'd up" stuff. Maybe these parents need a finance course. I would gladly teach it to them."

Leave a Comment

Note: HTML tags are not allowed in comments.